Lynette's Daughter, Cherly Prater, took Lynette's car and tried to keep it.
Cheryl Prater, Lynette Croll's Daughter had divorced her husband about the same time Lynette had a stroke - 11th November 2002. Lynette had given Cheryl $15,000.00 towards her legal fees but this wasn't enough for Cheryl. She believed she was entitled to more.
When Lynette was in the Dandenong Hospital Cheryl "borrowed" Lynette's car and then refused to return it. Lynette wrote a letter asking for the car to be returned, she went to visit Cheryl three times and Cheryl refused to open the door. In desperation Lynette contacted a solicitor to begin legal action. Lynette wrote, as a last try before court, the attached letter.
A week later the Bunyip Police called and told Lynette that her car was at the Bunyip Police station to be collected. Before someone is taken to court they must be given an opportunity to remedy the situation. This opportunity was done in the form of the Uniform Civil Procedures Document Rule 444. Cheryl consulted a solicitor who advised her that she had to give the car back.
Cheryl Anne Prater
42 Eulinga Avenue
Aspendale Vic 3195
Written under Section 444 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
RE: Disputed property
Applicants Complaint:
That you have been keeping the motor vehicle red Toyota
Sedan registration QUO433 with the GPS navigation system NAVMAN hidden and are
not prepared to make it available for collection and return to me.
Relevant facts:
The Plaintiff has
left a letter in your letter box seeking the return of the motor vehicle and you
have not responded
Relief sought:
The Plaintiff will seek from the court an order that you
make the vehicle available for the plaintiff to pickup.
Why the applicant
should have the relief:
This vehicle was loaned to you while I was in hospital and
did not need it. This vehicle was never given to you and verifying this is the
fact that no attempt was made to do a vehicle transfer. I now am able to drive
this car again and wish to commence a normal life driving myself to the doctor
and elsewhere as necessary.
Nominated time:
I nominate the date by which you must reply to this letter
before I formally make an application to the court as being 14 days from today's
date being the 13th day of March 2004.
This letter is written under Section 444 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
Yours faithfully
Lynette Croll